Secret Cubby
Antique storeSecret Cubby is a antique store in Findley Lake, NY. You’ll find it at 10378 Main Street, Findley Lake, NY 14736. It’s the only secondhand shop we currently track in Findley Lake, so the nearby list below reaches into neighboring towns.
Hours are listed below as the store posts them; they can change seasonally, so call ahead before a long drive.
Antique dealers price by research, age, and provenance, so expect fewer accidental bargains but far more depth per shelf — furniture, glass, jewelry, and collectibles with real history. Many dealers negotiate on larger pieces, especially for cash.
6 more secondhand shops are within driving distance, listed below, so it can anchor a longer thrifting circuit.
Store information
- Address
- 10378 Main Street, Findley Lake, NY 14736
- Hours
- Thursday – Monday 10:00 AM – 5:00 PMHours can change — call ahead to confirm.
- Phone
- +1-716-233-1002
Before you go
- Bring cash and ask politely whether there is any flexibility on price — many dealers discount 10–20% for cash.
- Check marks, joints, and repairs; a phone photo of the maker’s mark lets you look up comparable sold prices before you commit.
- Measure doorways and your vehicle before falling for a large piece — most antique stores are cash-and-carry.
- Sunday hours are on file (10 AM – 5 PM), so it fits a weekend circuit.
Thrift & secondhand stores near Findley Lake
The Eclectic Bird
Antique store99 Ash Street, Mayville, NY14.9 mi
Fr, Sa 10:00-16:30
Landmark Acres
Antique store232 W Main St, Westfield, NY15.2 mi
Monday: 10 AM – 4 PM; Tuesday: 10 AM – 4 PM; Wednesday: 10 AM – 4:30 PM; Thursday: 10:30 AM – 4 PM; Friday: 10 AM – 4 PM; Saturday: 10 AM – 4 PM; Sunday: 10 AM – 4 PM
House of Saraf
Antique store37 East Main Street, Westfield, NY16.2 mi
Catalano's & Silk Purse Income Tax
Antique store41 East Main Street, Westfield, NY16.2 mi
Westfield Village Antique Center
Antique store58 East Main Street, Westfield, NY16.2 mi
We-Mo 10:00-16:30
Thrifty Kitty
Thrift store59 East Main Street, Westfield, NY16.2 mi
Monday: Closed; Tuesday: 12 – 4 PM; Wednesday: 12 – 4 PM; Thursday: 12 – 4 PM; Friday: 12 – 4 PM; Saturday: 10 AM – 2 PM; Sunday: Closed
🏺 How to Price Antiques and Collectibles You Find at Thrift Stores →
A research method for valuing old things: identifying marks and makers, finding sold comparables, grading condition, weighing rarity against demand, knowing when an appraisal is worth paying for, and avoiding reproductions.
🏠 How Estate Sales Work →
What estate sales are, how to find them, how pricing and discount days work, sign-in sheets and early lines, last-day half-off strategy, etiquette, and how they compare with thrift stores.
Frequently asked questions
Where is Secret Cubby located?
Secret Cubby is located at 10378 Main Street, Findley Lake, NY 14736.
What are Secret Cubby’s hours?
Listed hours: Thursday – Monday 10:00 AM – 5:00 PM. Hours can change — call ahead at +1-716-233-1002 to confirm.
Is Secret Cubby open on Sunday?
Yes — Secret Cubby lists Sunday hours of 10 AM – 5 PM.
What kind of store is Secret Cubby?
Secret Cubby is a antique store in Findley Lake, NY.
Are there other thrift or secondhand stores near Secret Cubby?
Yes — we list 6 other secondhand, thrift, consignment, vintage, or antique stores within about 50 miles. See the nearby stores section on this page.
Browse all thrift stores in Findley Lake, NY or explore all of New York. Spot an error? Send a correction.
Listing last updated from public listings and open map data.