Mystery Spot
Secondhand storeMystery Spot is a secondhand store in Phoenicia, NY. You’ll find it at 72 Main Street, Phoenicia, NY 12464. It’s the only secondhand shop we currently track in Phoenicia, so the nearby list below reaches into neighboring towns.
Hours are listed below as the store posts them; they can change seasonally, so call ahead before a long drive.
Secondhand stores buy or take in used goods and price them to move, so the floor changes constantly; expect a mix of everyday clothing, housewares, and the occasional standout piece priced well below retail.
6 more secondhand shops are within driving distance, listed below, so it can anchor a longer thrifting circuit.
Store information
- Address
- 72 Main Street, Phoenicia, NY 12464
- Hours
- Saturday 11:00 AM – 6:00 PMSunday 11:00 AM – 5:00 PMHours can change — call ahead to confirm.
- Phone
- +1-845-688-7868
- Website
- mysteryspotantiques.com
Before you go
- Ask at the register which tag color is on sale this week and which is newest — the sale racks are cheap, the newest racks are where fresh donations land.
- Check garments under good light for stains and test every zipper; most thrift sales are final.
- Bring a tape measure and your key measurements — sizes vary wildly across eras and brands.
- Sunday hours are on file (11 AM – 5 PM), so it fits a weekend circuit.
Thrift & secondhand stores near Phoenicia
Formerly Yours Thirft Store
Thrift store1084 Main St, Shokan, NY0.1 mi
Tu,Th,Sa 09:00-13:45
Needful Things
Thrift store4119 State Route 28, Boiceville, NY5.7 mi
Fr 12:00-17:00, Sa-Su 11:00-16:00
Community CenterThrift Shop
Thrift storeMargaretville, NY9.2 mi
Mo-Th 11:00-15:00; Fr-Sa 11:00-19:00; Su 11:00-15:00
Reservoir Antique Mall
Antique store3187 NY-28, Shokan, NY9.2 mi
Monday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM; Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM; Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM; Thursday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM; Friday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM; Saturday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM; Sunday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Roger's Antiques
Antique storeShokan, NY9.4 mi
Memorabilia
Antique store3038 State Route 28, Shokan, NY9.5 mi
🛍️ Thrift Shopping for Beginners →
How thrift stores are organized and priced, how to inspect items before you buy, what the return policy usually is, store etiquette, and a first-trip checklist.
🔍 What Sells at Thrift Stores →
The categories with consistent resale demand — vintage tees and denim, workwear, outdoor brands, Pyrex and cast iron, video games, film cameras, textbooks, tools — with what to check on each, and the items that never pay.
Frequently asked questions
Where is Mystery Spot located?
Mystery Spot is located at 72 Main Street, Phoenicia, NY 12464.
What are Mystery Spot’s hours?
Listed hours: Saturday 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM; Sunday 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM. Hours can change — call ahead at +1-845-688-7868 to confirm.
Is Mystery Spot open on Sunday?
Yes — Mystery Spot lists Sunday hours of 11 AM – 5 PM.
What kind of store is Mystery Spot?
Mystery Spot is a secondhand store in Phoenicia, NY.
Are there other thrift or secondhand stores near Mystery Spot?
Yes — we list 6 other secondhand, thrift, consignment, vintage, or antique stores within about 50 miles. See the nearby stores section on this page.
Browse all thrift stores in Phoenicia, NY or explore all of New York. Spot an error? Send a correction.
Listing last updated from public listings and open map data.