Thrift & Secondhand Stores in Fayetteville, New York

Fayetteville, New York has 3 secondhand stores in our directory: 2 thrift stores and 1 antique store. Each listing links to directions, and where known, hours, phone, and website.

1 of the 3 carry Google ratings backed by at least five reviews. None of them belong to a national chain — every listing here is an independent shop.

3 listings have hours on file, and 1 is open on Sunday. 3 listings include photos of the storefront. Use the filters below to show only stores open right now, only stores with photos, or only one type of shop, then select a few to compare or plan a route.