Thrift & Secondhand Stores in Fayetteville, New York

Fayetteville, New York has 3 secondhand stores in our directory: 2 thrift stores and 1 antique store. 2 listings include store hours. Each listing links to directions, and where known, phone and website.

Colony Shop Antiques & Art

Antique store

6923 East Genesee Street, Fayetteville, NY

Encore Thrift Shop

Thrift store

118 Mill Street, Fayetteville, NY

Tu-Fr 11:00-16:00; Sa 11:00-14:00

Nearly New Consignment Shop

Thrift store

115 Chapel Street, Fayetteville, NY

Tu-Fr 10:00-17:00; Sa 10:00-15:00

More cities in New York

Buffalo (23)Kingston (19)New York (17)Niagara Falls (13)Ogdensburg (10)Brooklyn (9)Downtown Brooklyn (9)Ithaca (9)Syracuse (9)Ballston Spa (8)