Thrift & Secondhand Stores in New Albany, Indiana

New Albany, Indiana has 8 secondhand stores in our directory: 4 antique stores, 2 thrift stores, 1 vintage store and 1 consignment shop. Each listing links to directions, and where known, hours, phone, and website.

None of them belong to a national chain — every listing here is an independent shop.

6 listings have hours on file, and 4 are open on Sunday. 7 listings include photos of the storefront. Use the filters below to show only stores open right now, only stores with photos, or only one type of shop, then select a few to compare or plan a route.

8 of 8 stores

812 Vintage
812 VintageVintage store

212 Pearl St, New Albany, IN

Antiques Attic
Antiques AtticAntique store

145 East Market Street, New Albany, IN

Chestnuts and Pearls

157 E Main St, New Albany, IN

Grace Station Thrift Shoppe

3417 Grant Line Rd, New Albany, IN

Grantline ThriftThrift store

New Albany, IN

Mariposa Consignments
Mariposa ConsignmentsConsignment shop

222 Pearl St, Ste 102, The White House Ctr, New Albany, IN

The Mercantile New Albany

128 W Main St, New Albany, IN

The Odd Shop
The Odd ShopAntique store

155 E Main St, New Albany, IN

More cities in Indiana

Know a store in New Albany we have missed, or one that has closed? Tell us and we will update the directory.