ThriftStores.io

The 5 Best Thrift Stores in Tonawanda, New York

Ranked by review-weighted Google rating across 1,269 shopper reviews — a store with hundreds of reviews outranks a hot streak of eight. Includes thrift, consignment, vintage, and antique stores. Refreshed as our data updates.

  1. 1
    Attic To Basement RepeatsSecondhand store

    4.6(100 Google reviews)

    83 Broad Street, Tonawanda, NY

    Details & hours Directions
  2. 2
    Habitat for Humanity ReStoreThrift store

    4.5(123 Google reviews)

    1030 Niagara Falls Boulevard, Tonawanda, NY

    Details & hours Directions
  3. 3
    The Mulberry TreeAntique store

    4.4(26 Google reviews)

    49 Main Street, Tonawanda, NY

    Details & hours Directions
  4. 4
    SaversSecondhand store

    4.0(863 Google reviews)

    2309 Eggert Road, Tonawanda, NY

    Details & hours Directions
  5. 5
    GoodwillThrift store

    3.9(157 Google reviews)

    3177 Eggert Road, Tonawanda, NY

    Details & hours Directions

How this ranking works

Scores come from public Google ratings weighted by review count (a Bayesian average), so consistency across many shoppers beats a small perfect streak. We don't take payment for placement. Only stores with at least five reviews are ranked — see all Tonawanda secondhand stores including unranked ones, or browse best-of lists for other cities.