The 8 Best Thrift Stores in Naples, Florida

Ranked by review-weighted Google rating across 539 shopper reviews — a store with hundreds of reviews outranks a hot streak of eight. Includes thrift, consignment, vintage, and antique stores. Refreshed as our data updates.

  1. 1

    4.6(50 Google reviews)

    991 2nd Avenue North, Naples, FL

  2. 2

    4.6(49 Google reviews)

    325 5th Avenue South, Naples, FL

  3. 3

    4.8(9 Google reviews)

    859 4th Avenue South, Naples, FL

  4. 4

    4.5(24 Google reviews)

    300 5th Avenue South, Naples, FL

  5. 5

    4.3(100 Google reviews)

    968 10th Street North, Naples, FL

  6. 6
    LarkAntique store

    4.3(6 Google reviews)

    967B 4th Avenue North, Naples, FL

  7. 7
    St. Matthew's HouseSecondhand store

    4.0(279 Google reviews)

    3601 Tamiami Trail North, Naples, FL

  8. 8
    Carolyn'sSecondhand store

    3.7(22 Google reviews)

    400 5th Avenue South, Naples, FL

How this ranking works

Scores come from public Google ratings weighted by review count (a Bayesian average), so consistency across many shoppers beats a small perfect streak. We don't take payment for placement. Only stores with at least five reviews are ranked — see all Naples secondhand stores including unranked ones, or browse best-of lists for other cities.